Why Trust Matters for Customer Success

Software usage is just one driver in customer loyalty

A widespread belief shared by Customer Success professionals is that promoting software use early after the sale leads to less churn. It makes sense. But usage is just one factor leading to customer retention. Studies show building trust is equally important for retaining customers and growing revenue. To generate high loyalty and more business, SaaS leaders must pay as much attention to affective processes as they do effective ones. 

Usage: the good and the bad

We’ve all had the experience of canceling an unwanted magazine subscription. Perhaps we signed up impulsively after reading a good article on a plane, or subscribed as part of a fundraiser to help a favorite charity. We thought it was a good idea at the time, but eventually the magazines stacked up—we didn’t have the time or the interest to actually read them. Eventually when the envelope asking us to renew came in the mail, we just tossed it. Since we didn’t use the subscription, it had no value to us. 

The same applies in software subscriptions. If customers invest in new applications but don’t use them, it’s hard to justify the ongoing expense. That’s why SaaS companies pay so much attention to user adoption. Customer Success teams spend much of their time onboarding new customers and helping them achieve early results. It pays off. Data from Scout Analytics by ServiceSource suggests that customers who use their new software at least once per week over the first six months are about 50 percent less likely to churn.¹ 

But high usage doesn’t necessarily equate to high retention. In the wireless industry, for example, heavy users are more likely to churn.² Why? Experts cite poor service quality (dropped calls in particular), price sensitivity due to high monthly bills, and preference for more advanced capabilities they find somewhere else. Similarly in the SaaS business, “power users” tend to be the most valuable but come with a downside. They’re the first to notice company “warts”—software bugs, system downtime, or poor customer service—and may be the first to leave.

Factor ignored?

SaaS companies frequently overlook an important loyalty dimension: trust. Researchers define it as the confidence business partners have in the reliability and integrity of each other.³ Studies in technology markets show that high trust leads to affective commitment; in other words, people are inclined to stick with a supplier because they want to, not because they have to.⁴ The lower the trust, the more customers revert to calculative commitment, considering other alternatives and spending time weighing product costs and benefits vs. the competition. Relationship factors are therefore as essential as product attributes and market variables when it comes to loyalty. Companies increasing trust increase loyalty.  

Despite the numerous shortcomings of Net Promoter Scores (NPS®),⁵ its fundamental question, “How likely are you to recommend our product to a friend or colleague?” offers a practical example of how we view trust. Recommending a vendor to a friend or colleague, for any of us, is a risky proposition. Our trust in the supplier’s ability to satisfy must greatly exceed the chance of impairing an important relationship. 

Brain trust

Neuroscientists say we learn to trust people in much the same way we learn about everything else. A part of the brain called the striatum specializes in social decision making, detecting and evaluating levels of fairness, cooperation, and reciprocity. Social learning begins with a bias, or cognitive “anchor,” which is surprisingly sensitive to what people say about others.⁶ As we learn about people, we compare situational outcomes against our expectations and subconsciously adjust our mental anchors along the way. Through experience, feelings of certainty and fairness acquired from multiple interactions then grow into a generalized sense of trust, a bias which in turn influences our future decisions. 

Our evolutionary biology explains why we developed the need for trust. Humans became the most successful species on earth primarily because of our ability to cooperate and learn from each other. But not all people work towards mutual interest. We subliminally perceive social deviations as threats, which in turn activate the ancient “fight or flight” mechanism in our reptilian brain. Low trust means high risk, prompting us to avoid the situation in the future.  

How to build trust

Software companies can grow trust in a number of ways. When organizations carefully and consistently set and meet expectations, it creates harmony in their customers’ minds. When things go wrong, leaders taking responsibility, communicating frequently, and quickly resolving problems build confidence. And when administering policies, treating customers fairly helps, too. Since a customer’s trust perception is strongly influenced by what others say, companies must guard their reputations with the same vigilance as their intellectual property. SaaS executives should be especially concerned when they see low NPS scores, indicating trust is low and further investigation is warranted.

Customer Success teams play a critical role as well. They can create more mindful customer experiences that systematically build trust in addition to early usage. The trick is to examine the customer’s journey and design processes that satisfy a customer’s effective and affective needs. For example, besides helping customers learn new software, CSMs can sow the seeds of trust by simply making a personal connection during an onboarding call. Doing so increases a sense of relatedness which quells the customer’s natural, subconscious threat response when encountering new people. Customer Success teams that skillfully manage five critical moments in the customer experience create conditions for strong, trusting relationships to form. Lower churn and greater revenue from up-selling and referrals result. 

SaaS companies must create and deliver value to be successful, but their loyalty efforts must extend beyond increasing software usage. It starts by understanding human nature and the factors that ultimately drive renewal decisions. Deliberately and systematically influencing these factors in turn makes SaaS subscription businesses thrive. 

Excel-lens is a publication of Service Excellence Partners. We increase customer loyalty and business performance in the cloud computing industry. Contact us today.
Net Promoter Score (NPS) is a registered trademark of Fred Reichheld, Bain & Company, and Satmetrix

Sources:

1. http://research.scoutanalytics.com/churn/the-data-behind-adoption-and-retention-in-the-customer-journey/ 
2. Ahn, J.H., Han, S.P., Lee, Y.S.: Customer churn analysis: Churn determinants and mediation effects of partial defection in the Korean mobile telecommunications service industry. Telecommunications Policy 30 (2006) 552–568
3. Morgan, R. M., and Hunt, S. D.: The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing. Journal of Marketing 58, 20–38 (1994).
4. Ruyter, K., Moorman, L., Lemmink, J.: Antecedents of Commitment and Trust in Customer–Supplier Relationships in High Technology Markets. Industrial Marketing Management 30, 271–286 (2001)
5. Sauro, J.: Should The Net Promoter Score Go? 5 Common Criticisms Examined. Measuring U. July 22, 2014 https://www.measuringu.com/blog/nps-go.php 
6. Fareri, D., Chang, L., Delgado, M.: Effects of direct social experience on trust decisions and neural reward circuitry. Frontiers in Neuroscience, 16 October 2012

Software Adoption is a Matter of Habit

Six tips to increase user adoption by capitalizing on human nature

In the SaaS industry, customer retention rates depend heavily on the extent to which customers engage with their product, especially during the early stages. The more they use it, the more value they find in it, which increases the chances that they will continue to subscribe. In fact, data from Scout Analytics indicates that customers who use their new software at least once per week over the first six months of their subscription are about 50 percent less likely to churn.¹ Understanding this well, most Customer Success operations focus their churn reduction efforts on encouraging product usage. However, this approach is insufficient by itself because it overlooks human nature, the most influential factor of all. SaaS companies must change customer habits before product adoption is fully realized.

Creatures of Habit

How many times have you driven to work, but upon arriving, had no memory of the commute that got you there? Clearly, driving is complicated. You get into your vehicle, fasten your seatbelt, apply the brake, start the engine, put the gear selector in reverse, look behind you, back out, turn the wheel, apply the brake, close the garage door, put the car in drive—and that’s just getting out of your driveway. You process thousands of stimuli, decisions, and actions in a typical commute, yet it can all be done without much conscious thought.

How can something so complex become second nature? Our magnificent brains help us simplify life. Because cognition demands so many resources, our subconscious creates habits to increase efficiency. Although the brain accounts for only 2 percent of body weight, it consumes 20 percent of the body’s total energy.² To streamline, the basal ganglia recognizes patterns and creates shorter neural pathways to get the same job done faster and with fewer resources. The brain automatically rewires itself, enabling reflexes to perform tasks that once required more cognitive power. This subconscious rerouting happens all the time. By some estimates, about 40 percent of what we do every day is habitual.³

The Habit Cycle

Habits are made up of four things: a cue, a routine, a reward, and an underlying craving.⁴ A cue is something in the environment that triggers the behavior, the routine is the action, the reward is the positive outcome, and inner cravings are the motivation.

Let’s say you want to start exercising habitually. We’ll assume you want to shave off a few pounds because you don’t like how you look in the mirror. A better self-perception is your underlying craving. Next, to create the new habit, you follow a cue-routine-reward cycle. First, you set up a recurring reminder in your calendar (cue) and then go to the health club every time you schedule it (routine). After the first few workouts you'll start to notice newly toned muscles (reward). It may be difficult to repeat the cue-routine-reward cycle, but if you stay disciplined and patient, your brain rewires itself. Pretty soon, exercising regularly will be automatic. Simple enough.

The problem is that old habits are notoriously stubborn. This is because our brains always take the path of least resistance. Having been more efficiently converted and stored in the subconscious, habits become easier for the brain to recall and execute. Once neurons have been wired together during the learning process, the connections become permanent, so the brain must now expend more energy to substitute a new habit. Conscious repetition causes neural connections to strengthen, forcing the subconscious brain to eventually choose the new wiring over the old. If repetition is lacking, the brain simply defaults to the old reflexes. That’s why reinforcement is so important for creating habits and why change is so difficult. The more entrenched our behaviors, the harder and more frequently our brains must work to replace them.

Making Product Usage Habitual

You should view software adoption within the context of changing habits. Upon subscribing to your service, customers are essentially trying to replace one behavior with another, such as using your online database rather than an Excel spreadsheet to track their information. Your customers’ brains are wired to repeat their former behaviors, so the key to success is to be patient and vigilant, while smoothing their path to change. The following six tips can help:

1. Promote the Motivation—People ultimately change their behaviors because they are inspired to do so. In cases where a department head makes the software purchase decision, it is likely that many users won’t feel personally connected to the motivation behind it. Be sure to repeatedly reinforce your benefits with all users. Cultivate their desire to adopt new habits, such as explaining how the new software saves them significant time and effort.

2. Chunk Large Processes into Small Cue-Routine-Reward Cycles—Any process can be reduced to a series of repeatable steps, and stringing together smaller routines allows the brain to learn, adapt, and reuse skills more efficiently. Running a new financial system is a daunting task, but “paying a bill,” “reconciling a bank statement,” and “running a month-end report” are more accessible and easier for the brain to make into habit.

3. Implement Recurring Cues—Recall that every habit needs a sensory cue to initiate the autonomic behavior. You can provide simple triggers through e-mail reminders with embedded links to start transactions. For example, Facebook and LinkedIn constantly send updates to revisit their website and reconnect with friends, family, and business associates. If you identify and map the routines involved in using your product, you can associate a cue to enact each step.

4. Reward Frequently— Don’t leave progressive adoption to chance.  It is essential to track, display, and reward it at every turn. Recognize customer successes via web pages or e-mails when new users accomplish milestones. Note their “moments of proof,” drawing attention to the improvements that using your software yields. Be sure to recognize both initial and repeat successes to promote habit formation.

5. Leverage the Support of Others— Rewiring the brain is difficult and takes conscious effort. Use your cohort’s shared experiences to encourage fellow users. Whenever possible, train people in groups and let them interact. Just like Alcoholics Anonymous and Weight Watchers, social groups provide a safe environment and unmatched support for people undergoing changes in habit. User groups also increase perceived value and builds affective bonds between the company and its customers, which further reduces churn.

6. Be Mindful—Above all, be patient. Experts estimate a new habit can take from 22 to 60 days to form, depending on complexity, entrenched current behaviors, level of motivation and reinforcement frequency, and even the age of people involved. It’s a process that requires intense focus in the beginning, and typically includes false starts and frustrations along the way. Once the habit is established, however, it tends to stay for the long haul.

Software adoption is about changing habits. To maximize usage and minimize churn, your SaaS company should look a step beyond software features, focusing more on the human beings who use the product and the new habits their brains are attempting to form with it.

Excel-lens is a publication of Service Excellence Partners. We increase customer loyalty and business performance in the cloud computing industry. Contact us today.


Sources:

1. Scout by ServiceSource blog. 
2. Swaminathan, N. (2008) “Why does the brain need so much power?” Scientific American.
3. Duhigg, C. (2012) The Power of Habit: Why We Do What We Do in Life and in Business. Random House, New York. ISBN 978-0-679-60385-6
4. Ibid.