A revolutionary change may be at hand.
Many Customer Success teams work with customers to help them learn and deploy new software in order to increase usage and build relationships at a critical time in the customer lifecycle. Others perform an important account management role, providing ongoing support and generating renewals. Often, however, CSM teams fill their days responding to customer complaints or being pressured to push upgrades to compensate for high churn. If CSMs spend most of their time mending frayed relationships or engaging in retention heroics, managers should be concerned—perhaps the Customer Success function is really there because the company lacks successful customers.
Sound familiar? Take heart. This situation is reminiscent of the transformation that occurred in manufacturing Quality Assurance departments not long ago. The important lessons they learned can help you lead your SaaS organization out of the problem-solving dark ages and into a problem-prevention renaissance.
Learning from the Quality Movement
Reeling from tough economic times in the late 1970’s, Americans needed answers. Japanese brands Sony and Panasonic had decimated the American consumer electronics industry, while Toyota, Honda, and Nissan were busy thumping the Big Three auto makers. The Japanese produced significantly higher quality, lower cost goods, and consumers everywhere snapped them up. From the Rust Belt to Silicon Valley, the once-dominant American manufacturing industry was in crisis.
Then in 1980, NBC News ran a program entitled, “If Japan can… why can’t we?” The show revealed how the quality improvement methods we taught the Japanese after World War II helped them beat us at our own game. Dr. W. Edwards Deming’s work with the Japanese challenged conventional notions that high quality must come at a high cost. Their global success proved that high quality meant far less waste and rework, lower costs, more reliable products, and happier customers.
American industry got the message. After losing its way during the post-war boom, it was time for a new start. Led by Motorola, Alcoa, Ford, and many others, manufacturing rebounded by rediscovering quality methods, revamping operations, and regaining lost market share. Today, defects are no longer measured in percentages but in parts per million. It’s all due to a fundamental shift—manufacturers now achieve high quality not through inspection and remediation but by designing it into products and processes in the first place. Gone are large “test and fix” Quality Assurance operations, thanks to robust product designs, high capability production lines, and responsive supply chains. The modern, lean Quality function no longer requires scores of repair technicians but a select few quality consultants working upstream to ensure improvement never ends.
Enlightenment in Customer Success
Just as manufacturing defects crippled manufacturing companies, experiential defects now rob SaaS companies of millions in revenue each year. Too often after buying SaaS offerings, customers find features lacking, software difficult to use, information hard to find, and support frustrating and unresponsive. This leads to churn.
When your Customer Success team becomes a de facto “save desk,” it’s behaving just like the Quality Assurance department of old, reacting to problems rather than adding value from the start. Worse, factors affecting churn can appear at multiple points in the process, but these problems get funneled to the Customer Success team in the name of “efficiency.” As a result, the team spends its time solving avertible problems at great expense.
To remedy the situation, SaaS leaders must shift their focus to prevent churn in the first place:
• Create better products
• Deliver better services
• Strengthen customer relationships
To accomplish these goals, it’s critical to address the negatives that make customers leave and the positives that make them loyal. Leaders must dig deeper to uncover the cause-and-effect relationships that lead to better results. Doing so eliminates frustrations, saves time and money, and grows revenue through more successful installed-base sales campaigns. Given relatively low barriers to entry and increasingly crowded markets, companies that keep and grow hard-won market share will be the survivors when SaaS markets inevitably shake out most of the competition.
Joining the Renaissance
The spark that ignites change is close at hand. Now more than ever, SaaS executives and investors understand the financial consequences of customer churn, emphasizing continuous improvement and analyzing customer use patterns and satisfaction data to drive software revisions. Executives are also beginning to look beyond the technology and to the people using it, placing greater importance on the overall customer experience. They see that the art of up-selling, cross-selling, and referral selling begins with a clean canvas of happy customers. As helpful visualization and predictive analytics technologies arrive on the market and teams adopt time-tested process improvement disciplines, your SaaS company can build customer loyalty that transcends software development and involves all aspects of the business.
A three-level model helps focus improvement efforts.
Customer retention is critical for companies with business models that rely on recurring revenue. The “leaky bucket” that is customer defection robs
companies of precious revenue and profit. In cloud computing, cutting customer churn in half over the typical customer life cycle doubles company cash flow and gross margin.1 Even a small churn reduction pays off in the long term when millions of dollars in revenue are in play.
Obviously, improving customer loyalty is the key, but how? Where should managers start? I propose a simple, three-level model to concentrate on the customer benefits that lead to loyalty: Implicit, Explicit, and Experiential.
Implicit Benefits
Customers take certain things for granted, such as reliable wireless phone service, accurate bank statements, and bug-free software. People assume basic attributes come with the service, and when companies fail to deliver on these minimum expectations, customers have little patience. Chronic problems providing what quality expert Dr. Noriaki Kano calls “must-be” quality2 leads to customer defections in every industry. In Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) companies, churn can lead to the loss of half of a firm’s customer base during each renewal cycle.
This is why managers must make delivering the fundamentals a company’s first priority. In cloud computing, that means system uptime, secure data, error-free code, and basic product support. SaaS executives must get and maintain control of their technology development and operations processes or prepare for a rapid demise.
Explicit Benefits
Companies promise things during the sales cycle. When deciding between competitive options, customers evaluate each company’s “value proposition” and choose the best option. If promises don’t materialize, customer expectations go unmet. For example, a SaaS company may state that their software creates a certain type of report, but the customer later discovers it can’t. Customers may not return if the issue is severe and the dissatisfaction high enough. If a competitor offers comparable benefits, and changing providers is simple and cheap, potential for churn grows.
Marketing masters Michael Lanning and Lynn Phillips say companies should make strong value propositions their strategic foundation.3 First, managers must choose a winning value proposition, one that focuses sharply on a target market and offers a compelling alternative. Second, executives must deliver the chosen value proposition by translating it into design requirements, bringing it to market, and then providing it in day-to-day operations. Finally, the company must communicate the value proposition clearly and consistently in marketing, sales, and customer service. When promise-making and promise-keeping are in close alignment, customer expectations are reliably met and churn is reduced. An effective strategic management system ensures value propositions aren’t empty promises.
Cloud computing companies competitive in delivering Explicit and Implicit benefits will typically retain 80-85% of their customers from one renewal cycle to the next. But to raise performance to world-class levels of 95% or higher, companies must become proficient delivering a third type of benefit.
Experiential Benefits
Customers prefer to do business with people they know, like, and trust. How a company does business is as important to customers as the product or service they receive from them. When customers have lackluster experiences, churn increases. Just one unhelpful tech support interaction can end a business relationship, especially when the customer feels ignored, devalued, or unfairly treated. On the other hand, service companies that form strong relationship bonds enjoy significantly higher customer loyalty.4
Customer Experience Management (or Customer Journey Management) is a technique used to analyze and improve customer interactions. Managers collect data on myriad customer “touch points” (website visits, phone calls, e-mails, blog entries, social media, etc.) and plot each interaction against time. Patterns emerge where gaps and problems exist, and managers can use process improvement techniques, such as Lean Six Sigma, to resolve them.
While addressing functional gaps is the first place to start, research suggests a more mindful approach is the secret to achieving the highest levels of customer loyalty. Underlying all human
relationships are reflexive responses to subtle, social cues that can have a profound effect on conscious feelings and decisions.5 For example, our subconscious mind is sensitive to certainty, the ability to predict the future. When a Customer Success Manager begins an onboarding call by saying, “We’ll have you up and rolling in just fifteen minutes,” she provides subliminal assurances to the customer, producing a rewarding dopamine burst in his brain. If additional, beneficial cues accumulate during the call, the brain assigns a positive marker to the memory.6 Later, the brain reactivates the marker as it recalls the experience, allowing subliminal emotions to “weigh in” on the evaluation. When companies understand and proactively manage simple social cues through employee training, refined user experience (UX) design and other means, the resulting positive interactions lead to richly satisfying relationships and more loyal customers.
Loyalty troubleshooting is easier when managers focus on Implicit, Explicit, and Experiential benefits. When customer turnover is high, executives should attend to the basics. When it’s moderate, the priority becomes clearly articulating and consistently delivering competitive distinction. And when managers strive for world-class loyalty, being mindful of the customer experience is the path to success.
Excel-lens is a publication of Service Excellence Partners. We increase customer loyalty and business performance in the cloud computing industry. Contact us today.
Sources:
- Skok, David (2013). “SaaS Metrics 2.0 – A Guide to Measuring and Improving What Matters,” For Entrepreneurs blog
- Adapted from Noriaki Kano, Nobuhiku Seraku, Fumio Takahashi, Shinichi Tsuji (April 1984). "Attractive Quality and Must-Be Quality" (in Japanese). Journal of the Japanese Society for Quality Control 14 (2): 39–48. ISSN 0386-8230.
- Lanning, M. and Phillips, L. “Building Market-Focused Organizations,” (Gemini Consulting White Paper, 1992).
- Gremlera, D. and Brown, S. (1996) “Service Loyalty: Its Nature, Importance, and Implications,” University of Idaho and Arizona State University, USA
- Rock, D. “SCARF: a brain-based model for collaborating with and influencing others,” NeuroLeadership Journal.
- Damasio, A. R. (1996) “The somatic marker hypothesis and the possible functions of the prefrontal cortex,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 351, 1413-1420.
